Week5--Chapter 6The Benevolent Dictator--LIUJUNYU

 As an open collaborative platform where "everyone can edit", Wikipedia often gives people an impression of freedom, openness, and even some anarchism. However, Reagle tells us in Chapter 6 of "Good Faith Collaboration" that Wikipedia is actually a place that attaches great importance to norms, procedures, and community agreements. Here, "freedom" and "order" are not opposed to each other, but closely intertwined.

In this chapter, Reagle deeply explores Wikipedia's talk page and Arbitration Committee, and other mechanisms, revealing how these seemingly trivial pages and procedures have built a stable, credible, and sustainable collaborative environment for Wikipedia. The talk page is not only a place for disputes or debates, but also an important platform for community members to negotiate, clarify their positions, and find consensus. In these places, participants strive to understand each other's intentions with good faith.

Behind this culture, there is a key concept: Wikipedia does not pursue "perfect objectivity", but pursues "neutrality that can be accepted by all parties." This means that the resolution of each dispute is not determined by "who is right or wrong", but by finding a way of expression that is as balanced as possible through dialogue and negotiation.

ArbCom: If the discussion page cannot resolve the dispute, the Arbitration Committee will intervene as a final resort. Although this institution sounds like a formal judicial system, its foundation is still the consensus and conventions within the community. It is more concerned with the maintenance of the "code of conduct" rather than the judgment of the content itself.

Reagle emphasized that the Arbitration Committee embodies the governance philosophy of Wikipedia: decentralized but not chaotic; open and inclusive but not condoning malicious behavior. It is a manifestation of order, but not an authority imposed from top to bottom, but a system that grows from the rules and habits formed spontaneously by the community.

Reflection: What can we learn from Wikipedia?

Reagle's research not only helps us understand the operating mechanism of Wikipedia, but also provides us with inspiration on the governance of the digital public domain. In this Internet age full of "noise", how to create a credible, consultative, and tolerant community with different views is a challenge faced by all platforms. The experience of Wikipedia shows that only by striking a delicate balance between trust, rules and consensus can the vision of open collaboration be truly realized.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Introduction to the blog

This blog is a digital forum where students from Collective Intelligence in Practice: Understanding Wikipedia at the Hanyang University in Korea (2025) will discuss their weekly readings and activities. Each week you are expected to post a blog post on our blog and make a comment on another student's post. You can do so on one of the following three topics: a) You can blog about the readings for the next week. As you are expected to do the assigned readings FOR the lectures they are assigned to, you are expected to post your blog and comments BEFORE that lecture. An ideal commentary should be about half a page in length (~200 words), divided into three clearly labeled sections in which you: 1) summarize in your own words of materials you read; 2) mention any new, interesting, or unusual items learned; 3) identify at least one question, concern, or discussion angle that is either problematic in some respect or could have been elaborated more. This question is likely to be incor...
Read more

Week 1. My Recent Wikipedia Edits - Jeong seolah (정설아)

I made several edits to the Wikipedia page for 'Daegu'.  Daegu, located in the southeastern part of South Korea, is the third-largest urban area in the country, following Seoul and Busan. With a population exceeding 2.3 million, it is the fourth-largest metropolitan city in South Korea and the second-largest in the Yeongnam region after Busan. Often referred to together with the surrounding North Gyeongsang Province as Daegu-Gyeongbuk, this region is home to over 5 million residents. Known for its rich history and vibrant economy, Daegu stands as a key player in South Korea's cultural and industrial landscape. Below is a summary of the changes I contributed. 1) Summarize and link Sights Section:  - Improved clarity by changing “mountains keep many traditional temples” to “the mountains keep many traditional temples.” Mosque Controversy Section:  - Simplified a sentence by removing “and of the authorities.” Festivals Section:  - Made phrasing smoother by changing “tho...
Read more

Week4 - Review about the readings for the next week. - Jo HyeonSeong (조현성)

 1. Summarize in my own words of materials. The book is primarily about the openness of Wikipedia. Openness means that anyone can participate in the creation and editing of articles without any qualifications. Openness can be a double-edged sword. While it means that you can edit without having expert knowledge of a topic, it also means that you can participate even if you have expert knowledge. For experts, articles written by non-experts can come across as inaccurate knowledge, which can anger experts. This anger can also be a catalyst for Wikipedia to continue to improve. However, articles edited only by non-experts can cause misunderstandings and convey incorrect information, so openness can be considered a double-edged sword. In fact, it sometimes causes some conflict, such as Wales' negative stance. Openness also means freedom from copyright, which means anyone can take it and use it anywhere. That is why the knowledge of non-experts can have greater impact. That is why appro...
Read more